0 Items

Judge Invalidates Patent for a Down Syndrome Test

Posted by Administrator on 11/2/2013 to Down syndrome

A federal judge has invalidated the central patent underlying a noninvasive method of detecting Down syndrome in fetuses without the risk of inducing a miscarriage.

The ruling is a blow to Sequenom, a California company that introduced the first such noninvasive test in 2011 and has been trying to lock out competitors in a fast-growing market by claiming they infringe on the patent.

Sequenom’s stock fell 23 percent on Thursday, to $1.92.

The judge, Susan Illston of the United States District Court in Northern California, issued a ruling on Wednesday that the patent was invalid because it covered a natural phenomenon — the presence of DNA from the fetus in the mother’s blood.

The ruling was a sign that the Supreme Court’s decision in June declaring that human genes may not be patented because they are products of nature could make it more difficult to patent diagnostic techniques.

Judge Illston cited the gene patent case, which involved Myriad Genetics, in her ruling, along with a 2012 Supreme Court decision invalidating patents on a test used to determine the proper dosages of certain drugs.

“It’s hard to imagine patents on diagnostics surviving if that approach is taken,” Christopher M. Holman, a law professor at the University of Missouri-Kansas City, said of Wednesday’s ruling.

Paul V. Maier, chief financial officer of Sequenom, said the company would appeal. “We believe the court’s decision is wrong and misapplies or ignores the controlling law,” he said, adding that the patent involved a novel use of a natural phenomenon, not the phenomenon itself.

Until recently, women seeking to find out whether their fetuses had Down syndrome or other chromosomal abnormalities had to undergo either amniocentesis or chorionic villus sampling. Both are invasive techniques that obtain cell samples from the womb or placenta and carry a slight risk of inducing a miscarriage.

The new tests offered by Sequenom and several competitors take advantage of the fact that some DNA from the fetus can be found in a pregnant woman’s blood and can be analyzed with new genetic techniques.

Such tests do not completely replace the invasive ones, but they have caught on quickly and led to a sharp reduction in the use of the other tests. The noninvasive tests are now offered by Sequenom as well as Ariosa Diagnostics, Natera and Verinata.

In the current case, Ariosa filed a lawsuit in 2011 seeking a court ruling that its test, called Harmony, did not infringe on the patent controlled by Sequenom. Sequenom countersued and tried to win a preliminary injunction blocking Ariosa from marketing its test. The court denied the injunction but the appeals court vacated that decision and sent the case back to the district court.

Verinata and Natera have also been seeking rulings from the same judge that their tests do not infringe on Sequenom’s patent.

In her ruling, Judge Illston said that the presence of the DNA in the pregnant woman’s blood was a novel discovery but could not be patented because it was a natural phenomenon. And claims in the patent over how to detect that DNA were not eligible for a patent because they involved conventional genetic techniques.



Story Written by Andrew Pollack

Comments

6 Comments

Sukey
Date: 2/22/2017
perfektni rozhovor ala svist. jinak bych rekl,ze je to uplne naopak-kdyz cestu sundas hned,mas pocit,ze to proste nebylo na hranici moultsoi-nzda.ane kdyz sundas dlouhodobejsi projekt...
Jaylan
Date: 3/9/2017
Thank you so much for this artielc, it saved me time! http://hzltsctvbce.com [url=http://xwxszdrrl.com]xwxszdrrl[/url] [link=http://gtibmgonxc.com]gtibmgonxc[/link]
Brenley
Date: 3/10/2017
The'ers nothing like the relief of finding what you're looking for. http://ykykuzvxl.com [url=http://dgugtuxdb.com]dgugtuxdb[/url] [link=http://vkyupqh.com]vkyupqh[/link]
Jayne
Date: 4/14/2017
That's really shwedr! Good to see the logic set out so well. http://thfihtru.com [url=http://fdcnjyvzj.com]fdcnjyvzj[/url] [link=http://dqanxvkov.com]dqanxvkov[/link]
Amory
Date: 4/15/2017
Articles like this really grease the shafts of kndlgeowe. http://lyafsmqva.com [url=http://omfdggqj.com]omfdggqj[/url] [link=http://thlkuujnk.com]thlkuujnk[/link]
Ann Weaver
Date: 8/12/2017
This is a message to the Judge Invalidates Patent for a Down Syndrome Test admin. Your website is missing out on at least 300 visitors per day. Our traffic system will dramatically increase your traffic to your website: http://tdil.co/3p - We offer 500 free targeted visitors during our free trial period and we offer up to 30,000 targeted visitors per month. Hope this helps :) Unsubscribe here: http://priscilarodrigues.com.br/url/11

Add Comment